In 2024, a UK talent agency found Black influencers are paid 34% less than white creators with matching follower counts and engagement. It isn’t a new injustice. It’s the same one the music industry ran for a century, just wearing a different outfit.
The numbers
The UK figures have been measured more than once, by more than one organisation, and they keep landing in roughly the same place.
Every few months, a number does the rounds that should stop the creator economy in its tracks, and every few months it doesn’t. In 2024 the number was 34%. That was the gap SevenSix Agency found when it surveyed 300 UK influencers for its Influencer Pricing Report: Black creators were being paid a third less than white creators for the same deliverables, with the same size of audience and the same level of engagement.
It would be easier to dismiss if it were the only study, but it keeps being repeated. Two years earlier, MSL UK polled 600 influencers and found a 22% pay gap between Black and white creators, along with a detail that tells you a lot about how the money moves: white creators were nearly three times more likely to successfully negotiate a higher fee. Across the Atlantic it is worse. A 2021 study by MSL and the Influencer League put the US gap at 35%, and a 2023 MSL follow-up found that 73% of white creators had landed their first paid brand deal within a year of starting, compared with 46% of Black creators and other creators of colour.
Look closer and the picture becomes more uncomfortable still. SevenSix broke its findings down by skin tone and found creators with the deepest complexions earned 44.63% less than those with the lightest, averaging £928 per Instagram post against £1,675. Hair texture followed the same pattern. Creators with looser curls averaged £1,713 per Reel, while those with tighter coils averaged £800. At that point it becomes very hard to argue the market is simply pricing reach.
The excuses
Brands tend to offer one of three explanations, and none of them holds up for long. The first is that it’s about reach rather than race, but every study above compared creators with matching audiences and matching engagement. The gap survived anyway, and at the macro-influencer level, where the biggest fees sit, it sometimes widened.
The second is that the algorithm decides, which has more truth in it than brands would like. Creators and researchers have argued for years that recommendation systems under-amplify Black creators compared with white creators posting similar work. That suppresses the very growth figures brands then point to when they make a lower offer, so a platform’s bias quietly becomes a brand’s justification.
The third is that brands simply pay what the market says. The trouble is that brands are the market. They set the rates and negotiate the deals, and according to MSL UK they accept white creators’ counter-offers roughly three times as often as Black creators’. Calling that the market doesn’t explain the gap. It describes it.
There is a fourth factor people rarely say out loud, which is that talking about any of this costs money. In one US survey, 59% of Black creators said speaking publicly about race had hurt their income, compared with 14% of white creators. The industry is happy to profit from Black creators’ cultural influence, and noticeably less generous when that influence is turned on the industry itself.
A much older story
None of this is new. It’s the latest chapter in a long history of industries built on Black creativity that handed Black creators the smallest share of the reward.
For most of the 19th century, the biggest entertainment business in America, and a major one in Britain, was minstrelsy: white performers in blackface caricaturing Black music, dance and speech for paying white audiences. The culture being sold was Black, while the stages, the songwriting credits and the money largely belonged to someone else. By the 1920s the business had moved into recorded music, and labels were selling Black musicians through separate “race record” catalogues on worse terms than the white artists on their own rosters. Many of the people who built the foundations of blues, jazz and early rock and roll never saw meaningful royalties from records that sold in their hundreds of thousands.
Then there is Big Mama Thornton, who recorded “Hound Dog” in 1952. It became an R&B hit and earned her a few hundred dollars. Four years later, Elvis Presley released a faster, cleaner version marketed to a mainstream America that Thornton was never allowed to reach, and it became one of the best-selling singles of the decade. Thornton never shared in that success. Little Richard told a similar story about watching Pat Boone turn his songs into hits for radio stations that wouldn’t play the originals.
The Renegade
TikTok, for all its talk of democratising fame, ran the same play almost immediately. In 2019, a 14-year-old from Atlanta named Jalaiah Harmon choreographed a dance to K Camp’s “Lottery” and posted it online. It became the Renegade, one of the biggest trends the platform has ever produced, performed by millions of users and eventually by celebrities on live television.
For months, hardly anyone knew her name. The dance spread fastest through white creators with large followings, who performed it without credit and turned it into brand deals, press and new followers. Harmon, the person who actually made it, stayed uncredited and unpaid until a New York Times piece identified her, and only then did some of the recognition and opportunity begin to find its way back. Swap the record label for a platform, the song for a dance and the years for weeks, and it is the “Hound Dog” story all over again.
What’s changing
What is different this time is that the gap is being recorded as it happens. The Instagram account @influencerpaygap, run by talent lead Adesuwa Ajayi, has spent years publishing anonymised screenshots of what different creators were offered for comparable work, dragging the industry into a conversation about pay transparency it had avoided for decades. In 2020, Nicole Ocran and Kat Molesworth founded The Creator Union, the UK’s first union for digital content creators, so that creators could negotiate with the kind of collective weight brands can’t simply route around.
Neither will close the gap on its own. Still, minstrelsy’s audiences, the race record labels and the radio stations playing Elvis never had to face what today’s brands do: a dated, public, citable record of who the money goes to while the culture is still being made. That record is the reason this version of the pattern is being named while it is happening, and the reason it may be the first one that doesn’t take half a century to put right.







